The conventional wisdom is simple: Illinois taxes are punishing, Arizona taxes are low, and retirees who move from one to the other save money. That narrative is incomplete — and for a specific profile of Illinois retiree, it is wrong.
Illinois imposes a 4.95% flat income tax on wages, capital gains, and investment income. But it exempts retirement income — Social Security, pensions, IRA distributions, 401(k) withdrawals — completely. Zero. Arizona imposes no such exemption. Arizona's 2.5% flat income tax (as of 2023) applies to all income including IRA and pension distributions. For retirees whose income comes primarily from retirement accounts, the state income tax picture flips: Illinois charges nothing and Arizona charges 2.5%.
The Trap in Plain Numbers
A retired Illinois couple drawing $120,000/year — $45,000 Social Security, $50,000 pension, $25,000 IRA withdrawal — pays:
- In Illinois: $0 state income tax (all retirement income is exempt)
- In Arizona: $3,000/year state income tax (2.5% on $120,000)
That $3,000/year — $30,000 over 10 years — is money Arizona collects that Illinois does not. The Arizona property tax savings on a $350K home are real (~$4,500–5,600 less per year than an equivalent Illinois home). But the net savings may be $1,500–2,600/year, not $4,500. Many retirees doing back-of-napkin math miss the income tax flip entirely.
Have questions about what you're reading? A specialist can walk you through real costs, honest comparisons, and what's actually available right now — free, no obligation.
Talk to a Specialist →The Full Side-by-Side Math — Three Scenarios
Scenario 1: Moderate Income, Similar Home Prices ($300K)
| Tax Item | Illinois (Kane Co.) | Arizona (Maricopa Co.) |
|---|---|---|
| State income tax on $80K retirement income | $0 | $2,000/yr |
| Property tax — $300K home | ~$7,200/yr | ~$1,800/yr |
| Total annual tax burden | ~$7,200 | ~$3,800 |
| Winner | Arizona saves ~$3,400/yr | |
At moderate income and comparable home prices, Arizona wins clearly. The property tax gap is wider than the income tax reversal.
Scenario 2: High Retirement Income ($160K/yr), Similar Home Prices ($350K)
| Tax Item | Illinois (DuPage Co.) | Arizona (Maricopa Co.) |
|---|---|---|
| State income tax on $160K retirement income | $0 | $4,000/yr |
| Property tax — $350K home | ~$7,000/yr | ~$2,100/yr |
| Total annual tax burden | ~$7,000 | ~$6,100 |
| Winner | Arizona saves ~$900/yr — nearly a wash | |
At $160K income and comparable home prices, the gap narrows dramatically. Arizona barely wins.
Scenario 3: Illinois Pension Recipient, High Income ($200K/yr), Modest Home ($280K)
| Tax Item | Illinois (McHenry Co.) | Arizona (Maricopa Co.) |
|---|---|---|
| State income tax on $200K retirement income | $0 | $5,000/yr |
| Property tax — $280K home | ~$6,160/yr | ~$1,680/yr |
| Total annual tax burden | ~$6,160 | ~$6,680 |
| Winner | Illinois wins by ~$520/yr | |
High income in a modestly priced Illinois home — Illinois wins. The income tax exemption's value exceeds the property tax gap.
Ready to move from research to real conversations about this community?
We connect buyers with agents who know this market from the inside — real cost math, honest comparisons, and what's actually happening right now. Every agent is personally vetted by the Nova55Living founder. No scripts, no pressure.
The Illinois Pension Trap Specifically
This is the case nobody in the retirement relocation industry discusses: Illinois state pension recipients who move to Arizona discover that Arizona taxes their Illinois pension. Illinois pensions are exempt in Illinois — full stop. In Arizona, they are subject to Arizona's 2.5% flat tax.
A retired Illinois teacher drawing a $75,000 CTPF (Chicago Teachers Pension Fund) pension:
- Pays $0 Illinois income tax on that pension in Illinois
- Pays $1,875/year Arizona income tax on that pension if they move to Arizona
- Over 20 years: $37,500 in Arizona income tax on pension income that Illinois would never have collected
Where Arizona Definitely Wins
Arizona wins on total tax burden for most Illinois retirees who:
- Buy homes at comparable or lower price points to what they owned in Illinois
- Have moderate retirement income (under $120K/year)
- Are not receiving a large Illinois public pension
- Have flexibility on where they move (can choose lower-cost Arizona markets)
The property tax savings in Arizona are genuine and large. A $350K home in Maricopa County generates roughly $2,100/year in property tax. The same $350K home in Kane County, Illinois generates roughly $8,400/year. That $6,300 annual gap is real money and it compounds over time. Arizona's income tax at 2.5% narrows but typically does not eliminate that advantage at moderate income levels.
The Honest Bottom Line
Arizona wins for most Illinois retirees who buy at similar price points — but the margin is smaller than the "Illinois taxes are high" narrative suggests. For Illinois pensioners with high retirement income, the math is a genuine toss-up. For a narrow but real set of buyers — high retirement income, modest home price — Illinois can actually be cheaper.
Run your own numbers. Do not assume either answer. The correct inputs are: your specific retirement income sources and amounts, the specific home price you are comparing in each state, and the specific county in Illinois you are leaving (DuPage at 2.0% is different from Lake at 2.5%). The generic comparison produces the wrong answer for too many buyers.
Want the Math Done for Your Situation?
Connect with a Chicago-area 55+ agent who can model the Illinois vs. Arizona comparison against your actual income and target communities.
Get a Free ConsultationRelated: Illinois Retirement Income Tax Exemption Guide · Senior Assessment Freeze Explained · Chicago Metro 55+ Communities