Both offer private lake access in Georgia — but to different lakes in different counties 120 miles apart. Cresswind Lake Lanier: Hall County, 45 min from Atlanta, $339/mo all-inclusive HOA. Del Webb Lake Oconee: Greene County, 75 miles from Atlanta, lowest county tax rate in Georgia.
Cresswind at Lake Lanier and Del Webb at Lake Oconee are the only two major Atlanta-area 55+ communities with private lake access. Everything else about them is different. Lake Lanier is 45 minutes from Atlanta in Hall County — close enough to the city for regular access. Lake Oconee is 75 miles from Atlanta in Greene County — a lifestyle destination, not a suburb.
| Factor | Cresswind at Lake Lanier | Del Webb at Lake Oconee |
|---|---|---|
| Homes | 934 | 866 |
| Status | Resale only | New & resale |
| Price range | $300K–$700K resale | $300K–$600K |
| HOA/mo | $339 (lawn + cable + security) | Verify with Del Webb |
| County | Hall | Greene |
| Eff. tax rate (est.) | ~0.90% | ~0.72% |
| Distance from Atlanta | ~45 minutes | ~75 miles |
| Lake | Lake Lanier (38,000 acres) | Lake Oconee (19,000 acres) |
| Airport access | ~60 min to Hartsfield-Jackson | ~80–90 min |
Greene County’s ~0.72% effective rate is the lowest of any county where a major Atlanta 55+ community is located. This is a genuine tax advantage for Lake Oconee buyers — partially offset by higher HOA fees if Cresswind Lake Lanier’s all-inclusive HOA is normalized against Del Webb’s unconfirmed HOA structure.
Cresswind Lake Lanier’s Hall County location keeps buyers within realistic day-trip distance of Atlanta’s medical facilities, cultural institutions, and airport. Gainesville itself has a strong medical infrastructure with Northeast Georgia Medical Center nearby.
Del Webb Lake Oconee buyers are making a deliberate choice to step back from the Atlanta metro. Greensboro, GA has limited retail and dining outside the Lake Oconee resort corridor. The lake lifestyle is genuine but self-contained. Buyers who want to visit Atlanta grandchildren or use Hartsfield-Jackson regularly will feel the 75-mile distance.
Choose Cresswind Lake Lanier if: Atlanta proximity matters (family, medical, airport), you want a fully built-out community with established amenities and a proven HOA, and the all-inclusive $339/mo HOA fits your budgeting style.
Choose Del Webb Lake Oconee if: you are making a destination retirement decision, Greene County’s lowest-in-market tax rate matters, new construction is available at your price point, and Lake Oconee’s resort corridor (Reynolds Lake Oconee, multiple golf courses) is the lifestyle you want.
We can run the complete cost comparison at your specific price point and income scenario.
Talk to a Specialist