The ongoing monthly number that matters more than the purchase price over a 10–20 year hold
Have questions about what you're reading? A specialist can walk you through real costs, honest comparisons, and what's actually available right now — free, no obligation.
Talk to a Specialist →We already have a guide ranking markets by entry purchase price under $300,000. This is a different question. A $250,000 home with a $450/month HOA fee costs more out of pocket over a 15-year hold than a $320,000 home with an $85/month fee — the math flips once you account for the fee running every month for as long as you own the property. At $450/month, that's $81,000 over 15 years before a single special assessment. At $85/month, it's $15,300. That $66,000 gap is bigger than the difference in most of the purchase prices we compare on this site.
This guide ranks the markets we've researched by ongoing monthly carrying cost — the HOA or recreation-fee number that shows up every month (or its annual equivalent) for as long as you own the home — using the real figures published on each market's own hub page, not national averages.
Every other market on this page charges a monthly or annual HOA fee of some kind. The original Sun City and Sun City West communities in the Phoenix metro are the exception, and it isn't a marketing claim — it's a different governance and funding structure entirely. As detailed in our RCSC fee explained guide, the Recreation Centers of Sun City (RCSC) is a member-owned, member-elected nonprofit that owns and operates the recreation centers, golf courses, and amenity infrastructure directly — funded by an annual RCSC fee of approximately $540/year (about $45/month equivalent) rather than a traditional monthly HOA. Most original Sun City homes carry no monthly HOA at all.
That makes Sun City and Sun City West, on a pure carrying-cost basis, the lowest-cost access to resort-scale amenities (8 recreation centers, 7 golf courses, hundreds of clubs) of any community structure we've documented on this site. It is worth being precise about what this does and doesn't apply to: newer Phoenix-area communities built under a traditional HOA — Sun City Grand (~$160/month, estimate), Trilogy at Vistancia (~$350/month, estimate), and PebbleCreek (~$200/month, estimate) — do not get this exception. The RCSC model is specific to the original Sun City and Sun City West footprint.
Every figure below is pulled directly from our own market hub pages — not a national estimate. Ranges reflect the spread across the specific communities named on each market's page, from lowest to highest documented fee.
| Market | Typical monthly HOA range | Lowest documented example | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phoenix, AZ (Sun City / Sun City West) | $0/mo HOA + ~$540/yr RCSC fee | Original Sun City — no monthly HOA on most homes | Structurally different model — not a traditional HOA at all; newer Phoenix communities (Sun City Grand, Trilogy, PebbleCreek) run $160–$350/mo like any other market |
| Kansas City, MO/KS | ~$100–$285/mo | Hazelwood Villas — $100/mo confirmed (lawn, snow 2"+, trash) | Largest 55+ community in the metro at this fee level; Asbury Villas runs higher because it bundles water and an indoor/outdoor pool |
| San Antonio, TX | ~$84–$545/mo (site average ~$285/mo) | Willis Ranch — ~$84/mo | Widest spread on this list — the same metro has a ~$545/mo Mediterranean lock-and-leave product near TPC San Antonio with full exterior maintenance bundled in |
| Knoxville / East TN | ~$120–$220/mo | Fairfield Glade — ~$120/mo | Zero Tennessee state income tax is described on our own Knoxville page as worth more annually than the HOA fee differences between these communities |
| Indianapolis, IN | $135–$500/mo (metro-wide range) | Representative new-construction scenario — ~$200/mo (gated community services) | Del Webb communities (Britton Falls, Kimblewick) run $230–$265/mo and bundle lawn, snow, and amenity-center access |
| Las Vegas, NV | ~$105–$450/mo | A Pahrump-area community — ~$105/mo | Sun City Summerlin's all-in HOA estimate on a $500K resale home runs about $3,600/yr (~$300/mo); most gated Las Vegas 55+ communities cluster $200–$300/mo |
| Ocala, FL (verify exact figure) | Not separately dollar-quantified on our page | On Top of the World — 54 holes of golf included in the HOA | The bigger carrying-cost advantage here isn't the HOA number itself — it's that most Ocala communities carry no CDD bond, while comparable communities at The Villages add $1,500–$3,000+/yr in CDD bond obligations on top of HOA dues |
We connect buyers with agents who know this market from the inside — real cost math, honest comparisons, and what's actually happening right now. Every agent is personally vetted by the Nova55Living founder. No scripts, no pressure.
The cheapest monthly fee on this page — Willis Ranch in San Antonio at roughly $84/month — is cheap specifically because the amenity package is deliberately minimal: a pool, a splash pad, a clubhouse, and trails, rather than a golf course, multiple recreation centers, and full-time activities staffing. Compare that to the ~$545/month community near TPC San Antonio, where the fee is high specifically because it bundles full exterior maintenance and a Mediterranean-style lock-and-leave product. Neither number tells you anything about value on its own — only about what's included.
The same logic applies to the RCSC no-monthly-HOA structure in Phoenix. The annual RCSC fee is the lowest carrying cost on this entire page, but it funds recreation centers and golf specifically — it does not fund architectural enforcement, common-area landscaping outside RCSC property, or a sub-association's neighborhood-level obligations, which may exist on top of it depending on the section. A $100/month HOA that bundles lawn care, snow removal, trash, and water (like several Kansas City communities on this page) can represent more real value than a $60/month fee somewhere else that covers only a clubhouse and nothing on your own lot.
Before treating any fee on this page as a decision point, ask the HOA or recreation association for an itemized list of exactly what's excluded — golf cart fees, per-round green fees, exterior paint cycles, roof replacement, sub-association dues, water and trash, and reserve-fund contribution levels. A low headline number with a thin reserve fund can cost more in a single special assessment than years of a higher, better-funded fee elsewhere.
Purchase price gets all the attention because it's the number on the listing. HOA fee level deserves the same scrutiny, because it's the number you pay every month for as long as you own the home — and over a 10–20 year hold, the gap between a $100/month fee and a $450/month fee adds up to tens of thousands of dollars, often more than the price difference between the homes themselves. The Phoenix RCSC model is the clearest structural exception to the traditional monthly-HOA math in the entire country, but it isn't automatically the right answer for every buyer — a lower fee almost always means a smaller bundled amenity package somewhere. Read the itemized list of what's included before comparing headline numbers across any two of these markets.
Get Help Comparing HOA StructuresConnect with a specialist who knows this market from the inside — real cost math, honest community comparisons, and what's actually happening right now. Every agent is personally vetted by the Nova55Living founder.
Connect with a Specialist →