Parkland Preserve vs Reverie at Silverleaf

The CDD vs no-CDD showdown. Same market, similar product, meaningfully different 10-year costs. Here is the math.

Buyers comparing Parkland Preserve and Reverie at Silverleaf are looking at two of the most similar 55+ communities in St. Johns County: both gated, both age-restricted, both new construction by established builders, both in the World Golf Village / CR-210 corridor. The central question that separates them financially is not amenities or floor plans — it is the CDD. Parkland Preserve carries one. Reverie at Silverleaf does not. This page quantifies exactly what that difference costs over 10 years and what else changes between the two communities.

Side-by-Side Overview

Feature	Parkland Preserve	Reverie at Silverleaf
Builder	D.R. Horton (Freedom Series)	Dream Finders Homes
Homes	367	360
Age restriction	55+ age-restricted	55+ age-restricted
Entry price (approx.)	From $374,900	Contact builder (active construction)
HOA	$230/qtr ($920/yr)	$198–218/mo ($2,376–$2,616/yr)
CDD	$2,390–$3,924/year	$0 — no CDD
Master plan context	Standalone gated 55+ community	55+ enclave inside SilverLeaf multi-generational master plan
Construction status	Nearly built out — mostly resale	Active new construction
HOA covers lawn?	Yes — included	Yes — included
Lifestyle Director on staff	Yes	Yes
Pickleball courts	4 courts	Confirm with builder

10-Year Cost Comparison at $425,000 Purchase Price

Same purchase price at both communities. Property tax identical — same county, same millage. HOA and CDD are where the gap opens.

Cost Item	Reverie at Silverleaf	Parkland Preserve (Low CDD)	Parkland Preserve (High CDD)
Property tax (10 years, SOH cap applied)	$44,222	$44,222	$44,222
HOA (10 years)	$24,960	$9,200	$9,200
CDD (10 years)	$0	$23,900	$39,240
10-Year Total	$69,182	$77,322	$92,662
Reverie Advantage	—	Saves $8,140	Saves $23,480

At the Parkland Preserve low-CDD scenario ($2,390/year), Reverie saves approximately $8,140 over 10 years. At the high-CDD scenario ($3,924/year), Reverie saves approximately $23,480. The key variable you cannot know without pulling your specific Parkland Preserve parcel is which end of that range your lot lands on.

When Parkland Preserve Makes More Sense

The 10-year math consistently favors Reverie at Silverleaf on cost at comparable purchase prices. But cost is not the only variable:

Purchase price gap: If Parkland Preserve resale homes are priced meaningfully below comparable Reverie new-construction homes, the price differential can offset some or all of the CDD disadvantage. Run the actual numbers for the specific homes you are comparing, not hypothetical same-price scenarios.
Standalone 55+ vs master plan: Parkland Preserve is a fully self-contained 55+ gated community. Reverie at Silverleaf is a 55+ enclave inside SilverLeaf, which includes multi-generational neighbors outside the Reverie gates. If a completely age-segregated environment matters to you at all shared community spaces, Parkland Preserve delivers that; Reverie does not.
Location specifics: Both are in the World Golf Village / CR-210 corridor. Parkland Preserve is closer to the WGV golf courses. Reverie at Silverleaf is in SilverLeaf which has more walkable retail and services. Neither has a significant location advantage for most buyers.
Resale vs new construction: Parkland Preserve is mostly resale as of 2025 — you can see an as-built home. Reverie is still active construction — you are buying specs and plans for most lots. For buyers who want to walk through the actual home before buying, Parkland Preserve resale may be preferable regardless of cost.

What to Do Before Making a Decision

For Parkland Preserve: pull the specific parcel at sjcpa.us and confirm your CDD amount. The difference between $2,390 and $3,924 annually is $15,340 over 10 years — worth 15 minutes of research.
For Reverie at Silverleaf: confirm whether a SilverLeaf master HOA applies in addition to the Reverie HOA. Get it in writing from Dream Finders before contracting.
For both: verify current home pricing and confirm available lots. The market moves — this comparison uses $425,000 as a hypothetical; your actual comparison needs the actual prices for the specific homes you are considering.

The Bottom Line

At the same purchase price, Reverie at Silverleaf costs less over 10 years in every CDD scenario — the gap ranges from $8,140 (low CDD) to $23,480 (high CDD). The tradeoff is that Reverie is inside a multi-generational master plan and is active new construction with no existing homes to walk through. Parkland Preserve is standalone, fully 55+, mostly resale, and carries a CDD that adds meaningfully to your annual cost. Verify both communities' specific numbers for the specific homes you are considering before deciding.

Get both communities' current pricing and confirmed fee structures from a local agent who knows this market — and run the real comparison with the actual numbers.

Connect with a Local Agent →

All cost figures sourced from county records, builder disclosures, and listing data. 10-year projections assume flat HOA and CDD (both can change), 3% annual SOH cap on property tax after year 1, $50K homestead exemption, and identical purchase prices at both communities. Verify all current figures before making an offer. This page is for research purposes only.