Six markets, honest analysis — Jacksonville, Myrtle Beach, Hilton Head, Sarasota, Charlotte, and Raleigh-Durham compared on taxes, healthcare, climate, and community quality
Have questions about what you're reading? A specialist can walk you through real costs, honest comparisons, and what's actually available right now — free, no obligation.
Talk to a Specialist →Mayo Clinic 20 min from Nocatee. Florida Save Our Homes 3% cap. Atlantic beaches 10 min. $280K–$900K. CDD fees at Nocatee communities.
Full market →Horry County 3-layer tax stack (lowest effective rates in any market). No CDD fees. Atlantic beaches 5–15 min. $200K–$700K.
Full market →Quiet Lowcountry character. Sun City Hilton Head — largest 55+ community in SC. Beaufort County SC tax advantages. $350K–$1.2M+.
Full market →Gulf Coast beaches, rich arts scene. Higher insurance and HOA than other markets. Strong CDD fee presence. $400K–$900K+.
Full market →Four seasons, mountain access 90 min. No beach but Blue Ridge Mountains nearby. NC flat income tax (declining). $300K–$650K.
Full market →Research Triangle healthcare (Duke, UNC). Four seasons. Growing 55+ market. NC flat income tax. $300K–$600K.
Full market →| Factor | Jacksonville FL | Myrtle Beach SC | Hilton Head SC | Sarasota FL | Charlotte NC | Raleigh-Durham NC |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| State Income Tax on SS | None | None | None | None | None | None |
| State Income Tax (IRA/pension) | None (FL) | SC low w/ deductions | SC low w/ deductions | None (FL) | NC 4.5% flat | NC 4.5% flat |
| Property Tax Structure | FL homestead + 3% cap | Horry 3-layer stack | Beaufort Co. SC 4% | FL homestead + 3% cap | Mecklenburg — no cap | Wake Co. — no cap |
| CDD Fees Common | Yes (Nocatee only) | No | No | Yes (common) | No | No |
| Entry 55+ Price | ~$280K (Cascades) | ~$200K (Myrtle Trace) | ~$350K | ~$400K | ~$300K | ~$300K |
| Beach Access | Atlantic 10 min (Nocatee) | Atlantic 5–15 min | Hilton Head Island | Gulf Coast 15–30 min | None | None |
| World-Class Healthcare | Mayo Clinic 20 min | Charleston 90 min | Savannah 45 min | Tampa 60–75 min | Atrium Health (strong) | Duke / UNC 15–30 min |
| Mountain Access | None | None | None | None | Blue Ridge 90 min | Blue Ridge 90 min |
| Summer Heat / Humidity | Hot + humid | Hot + humid | Hot + humid | Hot + humid | Milder summers | Milder summers |
| Hurricane Exposure | Moderate | Moderate–higher | Higher | Higher (Gulf) | None | None |
| Annual HOA Range | $2,160–$5,040 | $2,160–$3,720 | $2,400–$4,800 | $4,200–$14,400+ | $2,400–$4,800 | $2,400–$4,200 |
We connect buyers with agents who know this market from the inside — real cost math, honest comparisons, and what's actually happening right now. Every agent is personally vetted by the Nova55Living founder. No scripts, no pressure.
Jacksonville (Mayo Clinic 20 min) and Raleigh-Durham (Duke and UNC 15–30 min) are the two markets with genuine world-class academic medical anchor institutions close to 55+ communities. For buyers managing complex conditions or planning ahead for healthcare access, these two markets stand apart from the rest.
Myrtle Beach / Grand Strand. Horry County's three-layer property tax stack produces the lowest effective rates in any market we cover at 65+ primary residency. No CDD fees. Lower HOA than Sarasota. Lower insurance than Florida Gulf Coast. For buyers optimizing purely on annual housing cost, the Grand Strand consistently wins.
Charlotte and Raleigh-Durham. No hurricanes, milder summers, Blue Ridge Mountains 90 minutes away. The financial trade-off is real — no state income tax benefit, no assessed value cap — but for buyers who specifically want the climate and mountain access, the Carolinas deliver something no Florida market matches.
Tied: Jacksonville (10 min from Del Webb Nocatee) and Myrtle Beach (5–15 min from Grand Strand communities). Both put residents within easy daily reach of the Atlantic Ocean. Myrtle Beach has 60 miles of continuous beach; Jacksonville has Ponte Vedra Beach and Atlantic Beach, which are higher-quality but shorter stretches.
Hilton Head. Sun City Hilton Head is the largest 55+ community in South Carolina and delivers a lifestyle character — golf-anchored, quiet, Lowcountry natural beauty — that none of the louder resort markets match.
Tell us your priorities — healthcare, climate, cost, or beach — and we will give you a straight recommendation.
Talk to a SpecialistConnect with a specialist who knows this market from the inside — real cost math, honest community comparisons, and what's actually happening right now. Every agent is personally vetted by the Nova55Living founder.
Connect with a Specialist →