The two largest 55+ communities in Fort Myers compared directly — amenity scale, golf structure, fee layers, price points, CDD exposure, and who each community is actually right for.
Pelican Preserve and Colonial Country Club are the dominant 55+ communities in Fort Myers. Both have 1,500+ homes. Both have championship golf. Both are established, fully built-out communities with active social calendars. And yet they are meaningfully different in structure, cost, and buyer profile. If you're cross-shopping both, here is the honest comparison.
Have questions about what you're reading? A specialist can walk you through real costs, honest comparisons, and what's actually available right now — free, no obligation.
Talk to a Specialist →| Factor | Pelican Preserve | Colonial Country Club |
|---|---|---|
| Total homes | 2,498 | 1,699 |
| Age restriction | 55+ | 55+ |
| Golf | 27 holes — optional membership, wait list | 18 holes — included in HOA (bundled) |
| Master HOA | ~$350–$500/mo | ~$250–$400/mo |
| Golf cost structure | Separate club membership + optional initiation | Bundled in HOA — no separate membership |
| CDD | Some phases — verify per parcel | None on most parcels |
| Price range | $350K–$900K+ | $300K–$700K |
| Town Center / amenity center | Expansive Town Center — theater, spa, restaurant, fitness | Clubhouse with dining, pool, fitness — solid, not resort-scale |
| Construction vintage | 2001–2022 (various phases) | 1990s–2000s (established resale) |
This is the most important decision point between the two communities. Colonial Country Club bundles golf in the HOA — you buy the home, pay the HOA, and you're a golfer. No initiation fee, no separate membership, no wait list. Pelican Preserve's golf is a separate optional membership with a limited number of slots and, historically, a wait list.
For serious golfers planning to play 4–5 days per week: Colonial CC's bundled golf is a simpler, more predictable financial and logistical structure. For buyers who want the option of golf but aren't sure they'll play frequently: Pelican Preserve's optional model means non-golfers don't pay for golf they won't use. The structure drives buyer self-selection — Colonial CC attracts committed golfers; Pelican Preserve attracts a wider mix of golfer and non-golfer buyers.
Pelican Preserve's Town Center is one of the most complete amenity complexes of any 55+ community in Southwest Florida — indoor theater, full-service spa, resort and lap pools, fitness center, art studio, woodworking shop, multiple dining venues. Colonial CC's clubhouse is well-appointed and fully functional but is not at the same scale. If amenity diversity and resort-level programming are a primary driver, Pelican Preserve's infrastructure is genuinely superior.
We connect buyers with agents who know this market from the inside — real cost math, honest comparisons, and what's actually happening right now. Every agent is personally vetted by the Nova55Living founder. No scripts, no pressure.
| Buyer Type | Pelican Preserve Monthly Est. | Colonial CC Monthly Est. |
|---|---|---|
| Non-golfer, $500K home | $350–$500 HOA + ~$415 taxes + ~$380 insurance = ~$1,145–$1,295 | $250–$400 HOA + ~$415 taxes + ~$380 insurance = ~$1,045–$1,195 |
| Golfer, $500K home | Add $400–$700 golf dues = ~$1,545–$1,995 + possible wait | Golf included = ~$1,045–$1,195 (same) |
| CDD phase buyer | Add $125–$233 = ~$1,270–$1,530 (non-golf) | No CDD most parcels = no change |
Non-golfers who want maximum amenity access and don't want to pay for golf infrastructure. Buyers who want the Town Center's scale — theater, spa, multiple dining options — as their primary social environment. Buyers comfortable with a larger community and resort-style programming at a higher price point.
Golfers who want predictable, included golf access without wait lists or separate membership management. Buyers who want a slightly smaller community with a golf-and-club social identity. Buyers at the $300K–$550K price point who find Colonial CC's lower price entry more accessible. Buyers who value simplicity — one HOA fee, golf included, no CDD on most parcels.
We can build a complete side-by-side monthly cost estimate for your specific situation — home price, golf usage, phase — before you tour either community.
Get Free Help →Connect with a specialist who knows this market from the inside — real cost math, honest community comparisons, and what's actually happening right now. Every agent is personally vetted by the Nova55Living founder.
Connect with a Specialist →