Del Webb Lake Providence in Mount Juliet is a fully established community with an active resale market. Homes range from sections built in 2006–2010 through more recent phases — a 15+ year vintage range that means some resale homes need HVAC, roof, and water heater replacement while others are nearly new. Del Webb Barton Village and Del Webb Southern Springs are in active construction — primarily new builds from PulteGroup at current pricing with current design standards.
The choice between new and resale is not simply about price. It is about what each option provides and what it costs — financially and in the living experience.
PulteGroup provides a 10-year structural warranty, 2-year systems warranty (HVAC, plumbing, electrical), and 1-year workmanship warranty. For a buyer who does not want to think about major repair costs in the first decade of ownership, this is real value. Resale buyers should budget for potential HVAC ($8,000–$15,000), roof ($15,000–$25,000), and water heater ($1,500–$3,000) replacement depending on the home's age.
Del Webb's floor plan evolution over the past decade has meaningfully improved aging-in-place features. Newer plans have wider doorways (36 inches standard), zero-threshold showers, first-floor primary bedrooms and laundry in every plan, and better natural lighting design. Homes built at Lake Providence in 2008 may have 32-inch doorways and shower entries that newer plans do not. If specific accessibility features matter to you now or will matter in 10 years, verify them room by room in any resale home you consider.
PulteGroup regularly offers incentive packages at active construction communities: interest rate buydowns (0.5–1.5% below market rate), design center credits ($10,000–$30,000), and closing cost assistance. These are real value — but they are tied to using the builder's preferred lender. Always get an independent mortgage quote before accepting a preferred lender incentive. The builder's rate with incentives is sometimes better than the open market; sometimes it is not. Calculate both scenarios before deciding.
At Lake Providence, you can see actual comparable sales going back 15+ years. You know what homes sold for, how long they sat on market, and what the price trends have been. Active construction communities have builder list prices but limited comparable sales data. Resale gives you price discovery that new construction cannot.
The 80+ clubs, the active pickleball leagues, the organized social calendar, the neighbor relationships — all of it exists from the day you move in at Lake Providence. Active construction communities build this over years. Buyers who want to be immediately embedded in a functioning social community should weight this heavily.
Motivated sellers at Lake Providence have room to negotiate in ways that builders at Barton Village and Southern Springs do not. In a normalized market, resale sellers can come down 3–7% from list. Builders have pricing integrity commitments to earlier buyers that limit their discounting ability. The negotiating dynamic favors resale buyers.
Tell us your priorities and we will give you a direct recommendation for your specific situation.
Talk to a Specialist