Maximum financial efficiency vs resort amenities and beach proximity — the full cost comparison
| Category | Myrtle Trace | Del Webb Grande Dunes | Seasons PCW | Cresswind MB |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HOA / Month (est.) | ~$100–$150 (absolute lowest) | ~$280–$320 | ~$180–$220 | ~$220–$260 |
| Median Home Price | ~$220K (lowest) | $400K–$700K+ | $250K–$350K | $320K–$450K |
| HOPA Certified | Yes — 55+ restricted | Yes — 55+ restricted | Yes — 55+ restricted | Age-targeted |
| Community Age | Est. 1980 — oldest | 2017–present | 2004–2017 | 2013–2022 |
| Beach Drive | 25–35 min (farthest) | 10–15 min | 15–20 min | Golf cart trail |
| Location Character | Conway — small city inland | N. Myrtle Beach resort | Murrells Inlet coastal | Market Common urban |
| 20-Yr HOA vs Grande Dunes | ~$48,000 less | Baseline | ~$28,800 less | ~$19,200 less |
| New Construction | Resale only | Yes — active | Resale only | Resale only |
Purchase price gap: ~$230,000. HOA gap ($170/mo): $40,800 over 20 years. Property tax gap (~$1,000/yr): $20,000 over 20 years. Insurance gap (~$1,800/yr): $36,000 over 20 years. Total financial advantage of Myrtle Trace over Grande Dunes: approximately $326,800 over 20 years. This is not an argument that Myrtle Trace is better — it is an argument that buyers should know this number before they choose. Some buyers look at it and still choose Grande Dunes. Many do not.
The beach is 25–35 minutes from Conway. For buyers who moved to the Grand Strand specifically to be near the ocean and visit regularly, this is a dealbreaker. That is the right call. Myrtle Trace is a Grand Strand community in the broadest sense — the lifestyle, the SC tax advantages, the coastal Mid-Atlantic culture — but the beach is a drive, not a quick trip. Be honest with yourself about how often you will actually use it before letting that drive time eliminate or keep this community on your list.
We can run the 20-year financial comparison for your specific home price target and lifestyle priorities.
Get the Numbers