HomeJacksonvilleStillwater › Compare

Stillwater vs First Coast 55+ Communities

Golf included + lowest HOA vs Del Webb resort amenities — the honest comparison

OverviewAmenitiesCompare
FactorStillwaterDel Webb NocateeDel Webb eTownCascades WGV
HOA/mo~$200–$280 (lowest)~$350–$420~$280–$340~$180–$240
Price Range$300K–$600K$450K–$900K$400K–$700K$280K–$500K
CDD FeeNone~$1,500–$3,500/yrNoneNone
Onsite GolfYes — Bobby Weed 18-hole incl.NoNoNo
Beach Drive~20 min~10 min~25 min~20 min
St. Augustine Drive~25 min~25 min~45 min~10 min
Dual PoolsNo — single outdoorYes — indoor + outdoorOutdoor onlyOutdoor only
BuilderLennarDel Webb / PulteGroupDel Webb / PulteGroupMultiple

Stillwater wins on golf value and total cost for golfers. Del Webb Nocatee wins on amenity breadth, beach proximity, and onsite dining for non-golfers. Cascades WGV wins on the lowest purchase price and St. Augustine proximity.

Stillwater or Del Webb?

Tell us how often you golf and we will run the 10-year value comparison for your specific profile.

Get a Comparison